Green Acting vs. Buying

Jul 30, 2012 by

green treeNewer, green technologies seem always to cost more up front compared to the conventional alternatives. So each of us has to make a judgement, for everything from compact fluorescent light bulbs to hybrid cars: Do the ongoing cost savings (and environmental footprint benefits, if that matters to you) more than offset the higher investment?

Act vs. Buy

Here’s an interesting infographic that takes a look at the buy green question from a bit of a different angle.

Let’s say you resolve to have your cake and eat it too by choosing the cheaper conventional alternative to save the extra upfront cost of the green option but also get the benefits of the green option. How would you have to change your standard behavior when using your old technology to get the same financial and environmental benefits you’d get from an equivalent green technology?

Acting Green vs. Buying Green
Source: eLocal.com

I think I wouldn’t count a ceiling fan as equivalent to central air conditioning, and the light bulb pictured is a compact fluorescent, but the comparison is to an LED. I’m curious to know the comparison for a fluorescent, since LEDs are really expensive. You could certainly encourage guests not to overstay their welcome by enforcing a two-use per flush policy! Still, I think this is a useful and interesting way to consider these and other green options.

What Do You Think?

Does this way of thinking about spending more on green alternatives help you decide whether to go conventional or green? Would you consider selling a still working conventional technology—say a washer—with a green option, or would you wait until the old item needed to be replaced?

Copyright secured by Digiprove © 2012 Kurt Fischer
  • http://retireby40.org/ Joe

    I guess I would wait for something to break before replacing it. I need to change out our toilets because they are not working that well and I’ll look for the green option when we go toilet shopping. I’ll probably put it off for another year though…

  • http://worksavelive.com/ WorkSaveLive

    I’d have to wait until my old washer went out before I’d consider buying a new one. It’s great to be green but there is a balance. I’ve read some really interesting things about those that really want to be green. Do you know that cows produce more gasses that are bad for the environment than most cars?

    • http://mymoneycounselor.com/ Kurt Fischer

      Yes! That’s why I carshare and don’t own a cow. :)

  • frugalportland

    That seems silly to me — make your guests deal with a gross toilet? 

  • http://twitter.com/IHEARTBUDGETS IHEARTBUDGETS

    Interesting graphic. The up-front cost of anything new is out of the question for us right now until it dies. And we definitely try to be green with our energy and gasoline consumption, but the toilet rule is ridiculous.

  • http://thirtysixmonths.com/ Marissa

    Hhahahaha 2 use per flush rule reminds me of the movie ‘She’s out of my league’

    Also, that grosses me out a bit. 

  • http://mymoneycounselor.com/ Kurt Fischer

    I think it’s unanimous: The flush-after-every-other-use policy is a non-starter.

  • Pingback: Weekly Wrap-Up, Good Reads and Mentions | iHeartBudgets

All original content on these pages is fingerprinted and certified by Digiprove